Immeritus
Toggle Content Main Menu

Toggle Content Advertisements

Toggle Content Chat Room
Currently chatting:

Toggle Content User Info

Welcome Anonymous

Nickname
Password

Membership:
Latest: flowersfan
New Today: 2
New Yesterday: 0
Overall: 11331

People Online:
Members: 2
Visitors: 62
Total: 64
Who Is Where:
 Members:
01: AliuIce0814 > Home
02: flowersfan > Your Account
 Visitors:
01: Forums
02: Forums
03: Your Account
04: News
05: News
06: Forums
07: News
08: Stories Archive
09: Forums
10: Sirius Fanart Gallery
11: Home
12: Forums
13: Calendar
14: News
15: Surveys
16: Home
17: Surveys
18: Forums
19: Forums
20: News
21: Forums
22: News
23: Forums
24: News
25: Forums
26: Forums
27: Forums
28: Forums
29: Your Account
30: Forums
31: Forums
32: News
33: News
34: News
35: News
36: Forums
37: News
38: Forums
39: News
40: Home
41: Sirius Fanart Gallery
42: News
43: Sirius Fanart Gallery
44: Surveys
45: Forums
46: Forums
47: Forums
48: News
49: Forums
50: News
51: Calendar
52: Home
53: Forums
54: News
55: Sirius Fanart Gallery
56: Forums
57: News
58: Surveys
59: Home
60: News
61: Forums
62: News

Staff Online:

No staff members are online!

Toggle Content Total Hits
We have received
50306148
page views since
June 2005

Forums » The Academy » Deathly Hallows » why was secret keeper not changed
why was secret keeper not changed
Home for all the speculation and discussion on the series' final installment. Please read the rules in here before going on a posting rampage!
Post new topic Reply to topic Printer Friendly Page
View previous topic :: View next topic
Author Message
Cyerra
1st Year
1st Year

Cyerra

Offline

Joined: Jul 12, 2007
Posts: 22

Post Post subject: why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 05:04 PM
Reply with quote

I just thought of something while reading an older topic that was out before the book.
Why if Dumbledore planned his death, if he knew he was going to die and the Head Quarters of the Ootp would be less secure. Why didn't he change the secret keeper before he died. Any Ideas?


Last edited by aoife on Thu Aug 23, 2007 08:56 PM; edited 2 time in total
Back to top
View user's profile
Fawkes_forever
1st Year
1st Year

Fawkes_forever

Offline

Joined: Jul 03, 2006
Posts: 61
Location: Forbidden Forest

Post Post subject: *Spoiler* why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 07:28 PM
Reply with quote

Well, I think deciding to changed the Secret Keeper would have looked kind of suspicious. The other Order members would have wondered about the switch, and I don't think he could really tell them "I'm planning on dying this June, anyone want to take me job?" Yes, he probably could have made up some other excuse, but maybe he just thought they didn't need Grimmald Place. I think the Weasley home worked just as well for them, and the Death Eaters don't seem to have found out anything important from Snape's search of it.


_________________
"I want to fix my memory...Draco Malfoy, the amazing bouncing ferret."
Back to top
View user's profile
Solitaire
Order of Merlin, First Class
Order of Merlin, First Class

Solitaire

Joined: Jul 13, 2004
Posts: 2171
Location: The girl next door - #11 Grimmauld Place
Immeritus Club Members
Restricted Section

Post Post subject: *Spoiler* why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 08:05 PM
Reply with quote

But don't forget that there also appears to be no need to change the secret keeper because when the original one dies, then the people who were entrusted with the original secret each become secret keepers in turn. That was the danger of returning to #12, that the 20-odd members of the Order becoming secret keepers diluted the power of the charms and enchantments put upon the house.

I wonder if Harry and Ginny went to live at #12 after they got married...


_________________
Back to top
View user's profile Send e-mail MSN Messenger
lovethedrama
1st Year
1st Year

lovethedrama

Joined: Jun 26, 2004
Posts: 87
Location: WI
Restricted Section

Post Post subject: Re: *Spoiler* why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 08:12 PM
Reply with quote

Solitaire wrote:
But don't forget that there also appears to be no need to change the secret keeper because when the original one dies, then the people who were entrusted with the original secret each become secret keepers in turn.

I think that was the reason for the question, actually. Why, if Dumbledore knew he was dying, did he not change the power of the secret keeper to someone else so that there was no danger of the power being diluted so much? Of course there wasn't much need for Number 12 after he died, and though the Trio did get good use out of it, had they not left, they might not have had the opportunity to save Luna and Ollivander. And don't forget, had that not happened, what chance was there for Harry to become the owner of the Elder Wand?


_________________
Carol

Back to top
View user's profile
giulia
3rd Year
3rd Year

giulia

Offline

Joined: Feb 12, 2007
Posts: 290
Location: italy, milan

Post Post subject: Re: *Spoiler* why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 08:41 PM
Reply with quote

Off topic (and sorry for it)

Oh, Soli, I had wondered, too, if Harry had used Sirius's old house. My conclusion is probabily not, since little James ask if he can borrow his room to Teddy and sleep with Albus... in Grimmauld Place there would be plenty of space. So, what happened to the house?
Giulia


_________________

SO HAPPY TO BE SORTED
Back to top
View user's profile
mollytype
7th Year
7th Year

mollytype

Offline

Joined: Jun 30, 2005
Posts: 776
Location: Stuck in the '80s
Restricted Section
Sponsors
Immeritus Club Members

Post Post subject: *Spoiler* why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Thu Jul 26, 2007 09:16 PM
Reply with quote

This strays off topic a bit, but knowing now that the fate of The Secret scatters among those who knew it answers a nagging question for me since POA. It never seemed plausable to me that Sirius would have changed secret keepers, since it seemed unlikly that he feared torture or death by enemies who would want to know where the Potters hid. But, if he knew there was a spy in the Order, and he were killed, and that spy would have the power to tell...now it all comes togther.

Lovethedrama, that is a good point- if 12 Grimmauld place was an indefinately secure refuge, the incentive for the Trio to forge ahead and take action deteriorated.


_________________



***Groovin' W+S Sigg by Dora* Groovin' Avatar by Star***
Back to top
View user's profile
Tarafina
Moderator
Moderator

Tarafina

Offline

Joined: Jun 15, 2005
Posts: 2147
Location: sadly not in Forks
Diggers
Immeritus Club Members
Restricted Section
Fic Sniffers
Sponsors
Moderators

Post Post subject: Re: *Spoiler* why was secret keeper not changed
Posted: Fri Jul 27, 2007 01:44 AM
Reply with quote

Dumbledore couldn't let anyone know that his death was planned, though. If he'd set up to change the Secret Keeper there would've been too many questions and he most likely didn't want anyone finding out his plan.


_________________



Back to top
View user's profile Send e-mail AIM Address MSN Messenger
Post new topic Reply to topic Printer Friendly Page

 Topics   Replies   Author   Views   Last Post 
Normal
No new posts The Burrow International Secret Santa 2009
~*~ gifts arriving ~*~
[ Go to pageGo to page: 1 ... 4, 5, 6 ]
80 cazzadragon 4786 International Secret S...
 Tue Jan 19, 2010 12:33 AM 
Mooncalf View latest post
No new posts The Burrow All-Homemade Secret Santa Swap
~*~*~*~ Addresses sent, Busy Crafting! ~*~*~*~
[ Go to pageGo to page: 1, 2, 3 ]
33 VolDoramort 2366 All-Homemade Secret Sa...
 Wed Jan 13, 2010 09:47 PM 
Pen View latest post
No new posts Immeritus Chat I'm on Immy! - a Secret or a Brag 5 Nineveh 611 Re: I'm on Immy! - a S...
 Tue Jul 28, 2009 04:11 PM 
Nineveh View latest post
No new posts Other HP Characters Dumbledore's biggest secret?
What do you have to say about Jo outing a character?
[ Go to pageGo to page: 1, 2, 3 ]
42 brenda.e 11197 Re: Dumbledore's bigge...
 Tue Jul 07, 2009 12:01 AM 
Witherwings3 View latest post
No new posts The Room of Requirement The Secret Villa Sidelines Part 2 0 Sirius Star 1011 The Secret Villa Sidel...
 Mon May 25, 2009 02:40 AM 
Sirius Star View latest post
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You can reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum
You cannot attach files in this forum
You cannot download files in this forum

Immeritus is an award-winning fansite and is not affiliated with JK Rowling, Scholastic, Bloomsbury,
Warner Bros, or any other huge entity claiming Harry Potter as their property.
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest copyright by Immeritus.
The art in our logo graphic is copyright HRB.
Interactive software released under GNU GPL, Code Credits, Privacy Policy